SigPDF
Uploaded our test document → typed a signature (Casual font) → placed it on the page → clicked “Confirm & Download Signed PDF” → “Subscription required to download.” No account requested at any earlier step — claims check out (“No account to try”, “100% browser-based”). Network: 1 outbound request total (a 121-byte analytics beacon); zero PDF bytes transferred — client-side confirmed.
The same page's “Why Choose SigPDF?” section promises “Instant Download — Once you are satisfied with your signature placement, download your signed PDF immediately. No email delivery, no queue, no delay.” And the fine print: “Your signature is permanently embedded in the document.” You built the signed file; they keep it behind a plan.
Verdict: The “upload-free” architecture is real; the free part stops exactly where your output begins.
Evidence: 01-signature-placed-download-wall.png · 02-instant-download-vs-paywall-text.png · network log (1 beacon, no PDF)
OnlineSignPDF
Uploaded → signature via image only (no draw/type — we generated one) → auto-placed → “Export PDF” → browser download fired immediately. Zero account, zero payment.
Network: 0 outbound requests across the whole session — the strongest local-processing evidence of any tool tested.
Notes: Background-removal threshold slider and auto-crop for signature images are genuinely useful. Copy is keyword-stuffed — old-school SEO.
Verdict: Fully free, fully local — the honest baseline. It loses on signing UX, not on money.
Evidence: 01-signed-placed-export.png · network log (0 outbound)
SignQuick
Uploaded → typed signature → placed → downloaded; celebration modal, “Download again”. No account.
Network: 9 outbound requests, all analytics (an A/B testing beacon); the download itself is a local blob: URL — the document never left.
Notes: The most careful legal wording of the bunch (eIDAS/ESIGN with honest limits: “some documents still require a handwritten signature”). Their paid side is a multi-signer workflow (5 docs/month free, then €2.99/send). Geo-served us Chinese by IP; the EN switch works. The type input lacks a label.
Verdict: Free where it matters, honest where it counts — the brand-shaped tool that acts like a utility.
Evidence: 01-signed-and-downloaded.png · network log
PDFedit.com
Uploaded → signature via image upload (draw pad exists but we used upload) → placed → Save → two-step “ready → Download” → browser download fired.
Network: 1 outbound request total (a rendering-engine WASM file from a CDN — not user data).
Notes: The heaviest privacy-claims landing page of the set (“100% free forever”, “no tiered subscriptions”, “no internet connection required”) and a full editor suite (forms, watermark, password-protect, certify, merge/split). A donation-funded indie tool; its manifesto: “No hidden accounts, no data mining, no paywalls.”
Verdict: Proves fully-local-free is achievable at suite scale. We differentiate on signing focus, not on suite breadth.
Evidence: 00-editor-state.png · 02-signature-placed.png · 04-download-complete.png · network log
iLovePDF
Uploaded (tool path is /sign-pdf — /sign_pdf is a 404) → chose Simple Signature (“Digital Signature” wears a crown = paid) → “Only me” → typed name → dragged the signature field onto the page → Sign → “This task has been processed successfully” → browser download fired. No account.
Network: At file selection, a multipart POST to api1s.ilovepdf.com/v1/upload carrying the PDF — your file is on their servers before you see the editor; processing is server-side.
Notes: The flow is heavier than the locals (fields + signers concepts, two-step placement); the download page advertises their desktop app.
Verdict: The ranking leader is genuinely free for single signatures — and genuinely server-side. Different bet, same price to you: zero money, plus your file on their infra.
Evidence: 01-editor-signing-options.png · 02-field-placed-sign-enabled.png · network log (captured upload POST)
Adobe Acrobat (Fill & Sign)
Uploaded → immediately redirected into a sign-in wall — before a single editing tool is shown.
Our test file appeared in a server-side preview pane next to the wall (with the UTS_Uploaded session token in the URL), under the words “Sign in to save your file or it will be deleted from our servers to respect your privacy.” Four identity providers offered, “no credit card needed”.
Verdict: The deepest wall we hit — account required before any functionality, with the file already resident. If the ranking is by authority, the experience ranking is last.
Evidence: 01-signin-wall-before-editing.png · network log notes
DocuSign
No anonymous PDF-signing path exists. Every call-to-action leads to trial.docusign.com (account trial). The one “100% Free, No Account Required” tool on the site is a signature-image generator — it draws or types a signature image for you to place manually; it accepts no PDF at all.
Verdict: The e-signature platform model: account + trial before any functionality. The strictest wall in the set — stricter than Adobe, which at least lets you upload first.
Evidence: 01-signature-generator-not-pdf-signer.png
Sejda
Uploaded → typed signature (with an honest disclaimer: “Sejda does not guarantee that the signature provided through this tool is legally binding.”) → placed → Apply changes → “Your document is ready” → free download. No account.
Network: At upload, a multipart POST to sejda.com/api/files/upload carrying the PDF — server-side processing.
Notes: Free-tier rate-limit UI exists in the page (3 tasks/hour) but did not trigger on the first task.
Verdict: Server-side but frictionless for single-sign — and the only tool whose own copy under-promises on legal effect.
Evidence: 02-processed-download.png · network log (upload POSTs) · signed output archived
PDF24
Uploaded → Insert signature → four modes (Type / Draw / Upload image / Camera — the fullest set we tested) → typed “Alex Tester”, picked a script font → placed on page → Save PDF (two-step) → “The new PDF has been created and downloaded.” No account, no watermark.
The completion screen offers “Delete the files from the server now” — the signed output is stored on PDF24's servers (a backend heartbeat runs throughout). The editor renders locally; the save goes to their cloud. You can delete it manually — if you remember to.
Network: 22 outbound requests — analytics, ads (DoubleClick funds the “free”), the save pipeline, and session heartbeats.
Verdict: Free, unlimited, feature-rich — but “local” is only half-true: local editing, cloud save with manual cleanup.
Evidence: 01-signed-and-downloaded.png (completion screen incl. delete-now link) · 02-download-complete.png · network log · signed output archived